Merwan Merchant

Pleader, a devoted disciple of Meher Baba, was given a list of ten circles by Baba, each containing the names of chosen individuals. Despite Pleader’s attempts to keep the list secret, other disciples, including Baidul, demanded to know their placement. When Pleader revealed Baidul’s position, Baidul confronted Baba, who refused to change the list, leading to a violent altercation with the other disciples. Pleader, who was given a list of circles by Meher Baba, was beaten up for refusing to show it. Baba later instructed Pleader’s mother to send the list to Him, which she did by mailing it to Adi K. Irani, who then gave it to Eruch. Baba took the list and burned it, emphasizing its importance and the secrecy surrounding it.